How the directory is scored
This site lists Utah property management companies and, when the inputs exist, assigns a Public Record Score from 0 to 100. The score is a transparency score built from public records. It is not a quality grade, an A–F mark, or a claim that one firm is “the best.”
If a required input is missing, the score is marked incomplete, or is not issued at all. A missing number is never treated as a silent zero that looks like a bad grade.
No companies are scored on this first publication. The formula below is the method that will be used when real rows are collected.
What every company card must show
Each fact on a card needs a source and a last-checked date. The fields are:
-
License standing, from the Utah Division of Real Estate lookup (License Management System search and the Division’s current system). The Division’s property management page is https://commerce.utah.gov/realestate/property-management/. Today, property management for others generally requires a real estate license and a registered company. A separate property manager license takes effect January 1, 2027, according to a Division page published November 5, 2026. The license type required must be rechecked on the date a card is scored, because the 2027 change will alter this gate. If an active required license cannot be confirmed, the card is labeled “License not confirmed” and no numeric score is issued.
-
Official disciplinary actions, only from Division of Real Estate records, with a link. Informal Google reviews or Facebook complaints do not count as official actions.
-
Google Business Profile rating and review count, copied exactly, with the date pulled. The rating is never invented or rounded to look nicer.
-
A BBB profile, if one exists: accreditation, the BBB’s own grade, a date, and a link (BBB.org). “No BBB profile” is shown as “no BBB profile.” It is not a failing grade.
-
Utah entity status and the year of initial registration, from the official business registration search. This page does not invent a lookup URL.
-
Doors or units managed, only when the company publishes a number, with a link and a date. Otherwise the field is “not published.” This number is never guessed.
-
For firms that manage HOAs, a check against the Utah Department of Commerce HOA registry where it applies. This page does not invent a registry URL.
The license gate (not points)
No confirmed required license means no numeric score. The card can still appear in the directory, with the license status visible, but it does not receive a 0–100 number.
The 0–100 Public Record Score, when it is issued
The arithmetic is public. The pieces add up to 100.
Review component, 40 points
(Google rating / 5) × 40 × min(1, log10(review_count + 1) / log10(51))
A 5.0 rating from 2 reviews is discounted. Fifty or more reviews receive full weight from the volume factor. The rating is the one copied from Google on the check date, not a cleaned-up version.
If there is no Google profile, or the rating cannot be copied from a public profile, this component is marked n/a and the whole score is incomplete.
Longevity, 15 points
One point per full year since the Utah entity registration date, capped at 15. If the registration date is unknown, this component is n/a and the whole score is incomplete.
Record, 25 points
- 25 points if no official Division of Real Estate action is found on the check date.
- A published deduction table will be used for formal actions. The working draft of that table, not yet frozen, is:
- License revocation, current: 0 points.
- Current suspension: 5 points.
- Older stipulated order or formal sanction that is not a current suspension or revocation: 15 points.
- This deduction table should be frozen before the first real scores are published. If the table changes later, the change should be dated in the changelog below.
- Unverified reviews, news stories, or lawsuits that are not official DRE actions do not change this component.
Transparency, 20 points
Itemize on the card, and keep the same items for every company:
- 8 points for a published street address (not only a P.O. box, unless that is the only public address and is labeled as such). That P.O. box rule is the working rule in the draft method; it should be applied evenly once scoring starts.
- 6 points for a working public contact method (a public phone, a public email, or a working contact form, checked on the date).
- 6 points for a published doors or portfolio figure, with a source.
BBB is displayed as a fact. It does not reduce a score for companies with no BBB file. A documented BBB accreditation may add a small, published transparency bonus of 2 points, with the 20-point transparency cap still applied (accredited firms cannot go above 20 in this component). That bonus is written here so it is not a secret bump.
How incompleteness is shown
- License not confirmed: no numeric score.
- License confirmed, but review, longevity, or another required piece is n/a: the card shows “Score incomplete” and lists the missing piece. It does not show a partial total that looks like a finished grade, unless the missing piece is clearly named next to it. The safer default is no total until the score is complete.
Corrections
A company can request a correction by sending a source. The last-computed date sits on the card. When a fact changes, the card is recomputed and the date is updated. This page should be updated if the formula changes, with a dated changelog at the bottom.
A correction form is not wired on this first publication. Email routing was not enabled at launch. The path can be added later without changing the formula.
Changelog
- November 11, 2026: method drafted. No companies scored.
- November 18, 2026: method published. No companies scored. The record deduction table is still the working draft from November 11 and has not been frozen.
Sources
- Utah Division of Real Estate, https://www.realestate.utah.gov/
- License search: https://secure.utah.gov/rer/relv/search.html
- Property management licensing update, published November 5, 2026: https://commerce.utah.gov/realestate/property-management/
- BBB.org, for profiles that exist
- Google Business Profile, copied on a dated check
- This page is a transparency method, not legal advice and not a recommendation to hire or avoid a firm.